Wicked Design – The value added by Design Thinking from an economic context , and into times of crisis. 

by Andre Vicentini and Juliet Leal-Ruokonen

In our course Design Thinking we understood the wide range context meaning of design that is becoming increasingly relevant in innovation management (Mauroner and Warnke  2020, p. 924) as compared to the business’ traditional understanding of design that is only applied to creation and development of products and services, limiting the business in its response to changes and uncertainties. It was an interesting reflection from the course lectures and recommended readings, the ways of thinking and ways of working together and with lots of learning we decided to emphasize in this post how Design Thinking can expand and contribute further to resolve unexpected challenges. 

Innovation to whom?

Developing innovative solutions to meet users’ needs is not solely the responsibility of design experts, rather it’s a collaborative, diverse, holistic approach involving multiple functions across the organization. When design strategy mindset is anchored in the business, its implementation generates measurable economic value (Mauroner and Warnke 2020, p. 925). 

Integrating design thinking

The first aspect is the integration of design thinking into the company’s business strategy adds economic value through collaboration, creativity, empathy, leading to higher customer satisfaction, when implemented (Mauroner, and Warnke 2020, p. 925).  

Insights and deep understanding of customers are the starting point of each problem-solving process (Mauroner, and Warnke 2020, p. 933). How you think and what do you do with the available information and then transform it into an innovative valuable solution to meet customer´s needs thus, positioning the company competitively. 

Design Thinking for unexpected times

In the article “Using design thinking to respond to crises: B2B lessons from the 2020 – COVID-19 pandemic” by Cankurtaran & Beverland, 2020 the text reflects further on the design thinking importance as it shows how design can tackle complex or “wicked” problems. Utilizing the example of the pandemic, that represented an unpredictable scenario, where maintaining a business operation became very stressful.  

The authors underlined that “maintaining the continuity of business activities amidst the disruption caused by the epidemic represents a ‘wicked problem’” (Cankurtaran & Beverland, 2020, p. 256), so they build upon the known stages of design thinking defined by Brown (2009) outlined by the three core spaces of design thinking as inspiration, ideation, and implementation, and introducing another three stage framework that breaks down into Disrupt, Define and Develop and Transform phases. 

Wicked Problem three stages framework

Fig. 1 Three stages of design thinking by P. Cankurtaran and M. B. Beverland (p. 257). 

Furthermore “Design thinking, with its emphasis on disruption, abductive thinking, and reframing, offers insights for the necessary pivot that many B2B firms will have to undergo to survive, and potentially, emerge stronger” (Cankurtaran & Beverland, 2020, p. 255) which highlights the importance of service design.

Conclusion – Naive Thinking

The fact that we are living a digital transformation makes us rely on a lot of it’s digital infrastructure but ultimately the idea is that naive questioning can highlight key stakes of our way of thinking like for example EMPATHY as seen here: “What we’ve had to pivot towards is more like, ‘what do you need?’ … we are now forced to think in terms of what is your peculiar need, right now” (Prothero, cited in Cankurtaran & Beverland, 2020, p. 257). to address more emergency solutions and a mindset of thinking outside the box, a “naïve questioning involves asking seemingly simple questions to uncover existing assumptions, and help generate ideas for new alternatives” (Cankurtaran & Beverland, 2020, p. 257). 

It is inherent for humans to think, imagine, and create. Design thinking harnesses these abilities,  shaped by evolution,  environment, and experiences, to solve problems and drive innovations that are essential to our survival and success and with the work we did during our Design Thinking course we could tiptoe on the pool of possibilities that a designer mindset can contribute. 

References: 

Brown, T. (2009). Change by design: How design thinking transforms organizations and inspires innovation. Harper Business.  

Cankurtaran, P., & Beverland, M. B. (2020). Using design thinking to respond to crises: B2B lessons from the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic. Industrial Marketing Management, 88, 255–260. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2020.05.030 

Mauroner, Oliver & Warnke, Franziska. (2020). Strategic Design. A Study on the Value Added by Design in an Economic Context. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/348871243_Strategic_Design_A_Study_on_the_Value_Added_by_Design_in_an_Economic_Context 


Posted

in

by

Comments

One response to “Wicked Design – The value added by Design Thinking from an economic context , and into times of crisis. ”

  1. mallika.kauppinen Avatar
    mallika.kauppinen

    Undoubtedly, Design Thinking today is used widely in Innovation management across organizations. Since we have learned and experienced the process of Design Thinking from the live sessions, we have a sense of how it can be applied to solve problems. However, what really interests me is this statement “how Design Thinking can expand and contribute further to resolve unexpected challenges.” For example, I wonder how Design Thinking played its role during the 2020-Covid-19 pandemic, when almost everything was conducted remotely.

    Regarding wicked problems, I came to understand that they cannot truly be solved. In accordance with Buchanan (1992), Rittel stated that the fundamental challenge is the existence of indeterminacy: we can neither stabilize any condition nor foresee future results. Thus, wicked problems remain unsolvable. Instead, what is vital is recognizing the complexity, uncertainty, and core values of contemporary issues. This makes it essential to foster teams that combine skillful expertise with adaptability. In the case of 2020-Covid-19 pandemic that you mentioned is the evident that wicked problems may not be solved, but the power of design thinking approach can manage the challenge.  

Leave a comment